Ok being new I am unsure if I should comment but du e to lack of responses here goes
#1 not sure about the focus point, it makes me look for my glasses so that I can focus on the water puddle in the centre. No real focal point for me that is of interest. Only a small section of cliff is in focus and everything else seems to be slightly out of focus. I would have used the water puddle and the edge of the midway ledge as a lead in to the picture.
#2 Again not sure what the main focal point is. Seems to be too much space on the left hand side, maybe a portrait crop/shot would have worked better?
#3 I find the rock ledge leads me across the photo, and not to anything in particular.
#4 I dont mind the framing of this one, only annoying factor is the pointy rock at the bottom of the image. Maybe cropping above will improve the framing?
Again I am a lot newer to photography so hope I am not treading on your toes. I would expect the same C&C from everyone in here.